My Berlin peeps were excited; even my mother said she wished she could go hear him.
And he spoke eloquently. “The walls between the countries with the most and those with the least cannot stand. The walls between races and tribes, natives and immigrants, Christian and Muslim and Jew cannot stand. These now are the walls we must tear down.” Yes.
But I didn’t love his speech. Did the Berliners love it? The video I watched stuck with a close shot of his face for all 25+ minutes, so I couldn’t see them, but I could hear them, when they stayed silent, and when they erupted into applause (at: we will finally end this war in Iraq and at: no more nuclear weapons and at: my country must take climate as seriously as you have here and at: the world is more interconnected than it ever has been).
And I found myself wondering whom this speech was geared towards. I found it… not quite in touch with the Berlin and the Germany I know.
The speechwriters clearly held the romantic notion (not uncommon among USAmericans) that Die Wende—the reunification of Germany—is a source of pure pride and joy for Germans. But in my experience it’s a fraught issue, with a good number of Wessies still upset at the drain on their resources and lowered quality of life, and a lot of Ossies missing the ideals and sometimes even the realities, of communist days. Meanwhile, many of the students in that crowd of 250,000 weren’t walking, talking, or even born when the Wall fell.
So Obama crescendoed with the glorious defeat of communism, the victory of capitalism and democracy… but the Berliners cheered far more heartily at the mention of the downfall of apartheid in South Africa.
And his opening, about the Airlift (about which I blogged a while back)… this story showcases the graciousness of the United States, taking pity on the starving people of Berlin despite the atrocities of the recently-concluded war.
What was he trying to accomplish with it? You better remember that we saved your asses? Or…remember once upon a time when we were a force for good?
I would have made the Airlift part of a resounding conclusion, to call America back to the magnanimous spirit of yore.
Yes, the historical stuff all felt a bit off—down to the mention of the Victory Column behind him as a symbol of…victory… when really, don’t we all associate the Golden Else (as Berliners refer to her), with Wim’s angels?? I think the Wings of Desire would have been a far stronger reference point than wars and victories, myself.






